Shadow Work

How to Quiet Your Inner Critic

A large jagged speech bubble looming over a small, calm rounded one

What is the inner critic?

The inner critic is the voice inside you that judges you, compares you to others and warns you. It often comes from a part of you that is trying to protect you, but in a really harsh way. You can’t switch it off, but you can quiet it: notice it, write down what it says, and answer it with care instead of fighting it.

How to quiet your inner critic in 5 steps

1. Notice when it speaks

Train yourself to recognize this voice. The voice isn’t you, and it isn’t who you are. The more you practice noticing it, the more distance you get from it. Even the way you talk to yourself matters: in one set of studies, people who talked to themselves using their own name or “you” instead of “I” handled stressful tasks better.

2. Write down what it says, word for word

When this voice talks, pay attention to the exact words. They happen inside you, and they aren’t necessarily the reality. Write them down word for word. On paper, a sentence like “You always mess things up” becomes something you can look at, instead of something you believe. Seeing a thought as words can make it feel less believable and less upsetting.

3. Give it a face

Try to picture the part of you that is talking: its age, its shape, whose voice it sounds like. This turns the thought into something outside of you, so it doesn’t take over. Again, this is a practice. The more you do it, the easier and faster it gets.

4. Ask what it’s trying to protect you from

Ask yourself what this voice is trying to protect you from. Often it’s rejection, failure or shame: if it criticizes you first, maybe no one else will. The more you go through this question, the more you’ll start to see patterns. Those patterns point to parts of you that are important to recognize. Our guide on how to do shadow work shows how to explore them.

5. Answer it with care

Recognize this voice and answer it inside, the way you would answer a friend who is scared. Sometimes this part just needs to be reassured. You don’t have to argue with it or obey it. Answering it with care gives you distance from it, and once you have that distance, it doesn’t take over as easily as before. Kindness also doesn’t make you lazy: in one study, people who treated a mistake with self-compassion were more motivated to improve than people who were simply told to feel good about themselves.

Why fighting your inner critic doesn’t work

It takes effort to acknowledge this voice, but it’s worth it, because the more you push it away, the louder it gets. Trying to suppress a thought can make it come back more often. And the louder it gets, the more easily it takes over.

Common things the inner critic says

  • “You’re not good enough.” It may be trying to protect you from being rejected, by making you work harder before anyone can judge you.
  • “They’ll find out who you really are.” Often a fear of being exposed. Psychologists call one version of this the impostor phenomenon.
  • “You don’t deserve it.” It may be trying to protect you from losing something, by keeping you from getting attached to it.
  • “It’s too good for you.” Similar: if you don’t reach for it, you can’t be disappointed.
  • “Don’t say that, you’ll look stupid.” It’s trying to protect you from shame in front of others.
  • “Everyone else has it figured out.” Comparison can be a way to stay alert to where you might fall behind.

Where does the inner critic come from?

This voice often comes from criticism you heard early in life, from high standards around you, or from a need to stay safe. In one long-term study, children whose parents were more restrictive and rejecting at age 5 tended to be more self-critical as teenagers, and that self-criticism carried into adulthood. That isn’t about blaming anyone. The voice learned to protect you in the best way it knew.

How Within helps

Within helps you listen to the voice talking inside you, and answer it with reassurance next time. When a critical thought takes over, you can write it in the app and follow a few steps to look at it from the outside and let it go. The thought passes, but what you learned stays saved in the app. Over time, you see which voices keep showing up in your life, and your relationship with yourself can get kinder.

Try Within for free on iOS and Android.

Download Within on the App Store
Get Within on Google Play

Frequently asked questions

Is the inner critic the same as low self-esteem?

Not exactly. Low self-esteem is how you see yourself overall. The inner critic is the voice that keeps that view going, one comment at a time. Quieting the voice is often one way to start feeling better about yourself.

Can you get rid of your inner critic completely?

Probably not, and you don’t need to. Most people hear a critical voice sometimes. The goal is to hear it without believing everything it says, so it gets quieter and takes over less often.

When should I talk to a therapist about it?

If the voice is there most of the day, if it stops you from doing things that matter to you, or if it comes with hopelessness, talk to a professional. If you’re having thoughts of hurting yourself, call or text 988 in the US, or your local emergency number.

Keep reading